The honest read
cast iron skillet
What independent testers and owner communities have said about cast iron skillets — their view, not ours. Read and written up on August 10, 2026.
Test kitchens land in different places on 'best overall.' Cook's Illustrated put the $200 Smithey No. 12 on top for searing, baking, and release, but named the plain Lodge 12-inch a Best Buy with equivalent performance for a fraction of the price. Wirecutter, after testing 16 skillets, went the other way and picked a Lodge as its favorite for being lighter and releasing food easily. Tom's Guide ranked an enameled Le Creuset first with a bare Lodge as a close, best-value second.
For enameled cast iron, America's Test Kitchen and Tom's Guide both point to Le Creuset's Signature Skillet, with a KitchenAid enameled pan called out as the cheaper Best Buy alternative. Both note that enamel never seasons into a true nonstick surface the way bare iron does, so it's judged on cleaning ease and no-seasoning convenience rather than release performance.
The Kitchn's hands-on comparison and a long-running owner forum thread both back up the lab findings from their own kitchen use: boutique pans like Field, Finex, and Smithey heat faster and feel lighter, and their smoother factory surfaces release food better out of the box, but a well-seasoned plain Lodge closes much of that gap over time and sears meat just as well in practice.
Where they agree
Lodge's plain 12-inch skillet is repeatedly the budget pick that performs close to pans costing several times more
Enameled cast iron never seasons into a true nonstick surface, so it's judged separately from bare iron
Heavier pans hold heat more steadily for searing but are harder to lift than lighter ones
Smooth-surfaced artisan pans release food better new, though a well-used Lodge narrows that gap
Where they don't
No agreement on the single best skillet: Cook's Illustrated crowned the $200 Smithey, Wirecutter and Tom's Guide favored a Lodge or Le Creuset instead
None of these sources ran controlled long-term testing on warping, rust resistance, or seasoning durability over years
Who said it
We don't test products, and we can't tell you which reviews online are real. What we can do is leave out the voices that get paid when you buy, and show you the ones we used.
professional test-kitchen lab · cooksillustrated.com
Smithey No. 12 aced all tests; Lodge 12-inch named Best Buy with equivalent performance for far less
professional test-kitchen lab · americastestkitchen.com
Le Creuset Signature Skillet is the favorite; KitchenAid enameled is the Best Buy; enamel never becomes truly nonstick
independent testing outfit · x.com
After testing 16 skillets, Lodge Chef Collection 12-inch was favorite for being lighter and releasing food easily
consumer-tech lifestyle review desk · tomsguide.com
Le Creuset Enameled Signature ranked best overall; bare Lodge ranked close second and best value
food publication reviewer · thekitchn.com
Boutique pans heat faster and feel lighter, but a plain Lodge sears just as well in practice
long-running owner forum thread · tnttt.com
Owners of Lodge and Le Creuset pans say the lab findings matched their own kitchen experience
What fits what you asked for
Matched to the words in the question and nothing else — we know nothing else about you.
Lodge 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet
best value or everyday workhorse angle
Called a Best Buy offering equivalent performance to pans costing four times as much
Smithey Ironware No. 12 Cast Iron Skillet
best raw cooking performance, money no object
Praised for a smooth, polished interior that aced searing, baking, and browning tests
Le Creuset Enameled Signature Skillet
low-maintenance, no-seasoning-required angle
Named top pick by two review desks for easy cleaning and searing without needing seasoning
Field Company No. 10/8 Skillet
lighter-weight, boutique-finish angle
Described as noticeably lighter than Lodge with a smoother factory surface, at a premium price
Shopping this on Amazon
Whatever you settle on, starting there through this link sends a percentage to All Good People — at no extra cost to you. Look for Amazon's own pick badge on the listing; it's a decent guard against a brand-new seller with suspiciously perfect reviews.
Some links are affiliate links: buying through them sends a percentage to All Good People at no extra cost to you. It never changes what the sources said.
Ask about something else
We don't test products, and we can't tell you which reviews online are real. What we can do is leave out the voices that get paid when you buy, and show you the ones we used. A question nobody has asked before takes a few minutes to read up on, and you get its page straight away to come back to. Answers become pages anyone can read, so ask about the product — we keep nothing about you.